The short version
A cash-out refinance on an investment property replaces your existing mortgage — or a free-and-clear title — with a bigger loan and hands you the difference in cash. Lenders treat it as the riskiest common transaction type, because it stacks the two things they charge the most for: investment occupancy and cash-out. That means lower loan-to-value caps, seasoning requirements, and pricing adders that a primary-home refi never sees. None of that makes it a bad tool. It's arguably the best tool in real estate investing. It just means you should know the rules before you count on the proceeds.
LTV caps: plan on 70-75%, not 80%
On a primary residence, conventional cash-out goes to 80% LTV. On an investment property, agency guidelines cap a one-unit cash-out at 75% — and 70% for 2-4 unit properties. DSCR lenders land in the same zone: most cap cash-out at 70-75%, with the best pricing reserved for 65% and below. Treat 75% as the ceiling and anything above it as a rare exception, not a strategy.
That cap does the heavy lifting in your deal math. A rental that appraises at $400,000 with a $220,000 balance doesn't have $180,000 of usable equity — it has about $80,000 before closing costs ($400,000 × 0.75 = $300,000 new loan, minus the $220,000 payoff). Run this number honestly before you promise anyone, including yourself, what the refi will fund.
Seasoning: how long you have to own it first
Seasoning is the waiting period before a lender will size a cash-out loan off the current appraised value. Conventional loans generally require 12 months of ownership before a cash-out refinance. DSCR lenders are usually looser — many allow cash-out at appraised value after 6 months, and a few go shorter with strong compensating factors.
The big exception is delayed financing. If you bought the property with cash, you can refinance immediately — no seasoning — but the loan is capped at your documented purchase price plus closing costs, not the new appraised value. That distinction matters for value-add deals: delayed financing gets your purchase capital back fast, but it gives you zero credit for rehab-driven appreciation. Investors who forced value usually wait out the seasoning clock so the loan is sized off the new, higher appraisal.
Why cash-out pricing is wider
Agency pricing is built from loan-level price adjustments (LLPAs) — risk-based fees, expressed in points, that stack up and get converted into your rate. An investment-property cash-out triggers two of the biggest adders on the grid: the investment-occupancy adder and the cash-out adder. Together they can add several points of cost at higher LTVs, which lenders typically translate into a meaningfully higher rate rather than an upfront charge. DSCR lenders do the same thing with rate adjustments for cash-out, LTV band, loan size, credit score, and coverage ratio.
Two practical takeaways. First, a cash-out will always price wider than a rate-term refi or purchase on the same property — budget for that instead of being surprised by it. Second, the adders shrink as LTV drops. Moving from 75% down to 70% or 65% often buys a visibly better rate tier, sometimes worth more over your hold period than the extra cash you left behind. Price two or three loan amounts before you pick one.
The BRRRR math, worked
Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat runs entirely on this loan. Here's the canonical version with real numbers:
- Buy: $200,000 purchase, paid in cash (or with a bridge loan you'll retire at the refi).
- Rehab: $40,000 in renovations. Total capital in: $240,000.
- Rent: lease it at market rent so the property can carry the new debt.
- Refinance: the property appraises at $320,000. At 75% LTV, the new loan is $320,000 × 0.75 = $240,000.
The refi returns your entire $240,000 — every dollar of capital back out — and you still own a cash-flowing property with $80,000 of equity ($320,000 value against a $240,000 loan). Repeat with the same capital on the next deal.
The two failure points are the appraisal and the rent. If the appraisal comes in at $290,000 instead, the loan drops to $217,500 and $22,500 stays trapped in the deal. And on a DSCR loan, the qualifying test is rent ÷ the new payment — a bigger loan means a bigger payment, so an aggressive cash-out can fail the coverage ratio even when the LTV pencils.
Conventional vs DSCR: pick your lane
| Factor | Conventional | DSCR |
|---|---|---|
| Qualifies on | Your personal income and DTI | The property's rent vs its payment |
| Max cash-out LTV | 75% (70% for 2-4 units) | Typically 70-75% |
| Seasoning | Generally 12 months | Often 6 months |
| Financed-property limit | 10 properties max | No hard limit |
| Documentation | Tax returns, W-2s or full self-employed docs | Lease or market rent; no tax returns |
| Prepayment penalty | None | Common, often 3-5 years |
| Vesting | Personal name only | LLC vesting usually allowed |
Conventional usually wins on price if you cleanly qualify. DSCR wins when depreciation makes your tax returns look poor, your DTI is already loaded with other mortgages, you've hit the 10 financed-property limit, or you want the loan in an LLC. The main tax you pay for that flexibility is slightly wider pricing and a prepayment penalty — which matters a lot if you might sell or refi again inside a few years.
Traps to flag before you sign
- Counting equity instead of lendable equity. Your usable number is capped LTV minus payoff minus closing costs — always smaller than the equity headline.
- Refinancing into a prepay penalty right before a sale. A 5-year step-down penalty on a property you plan to flip in 18 months is an expensive mistake.
- Title seasoning surprises. Moving the property in or out of an LLC right before the refi can reset clocks or trip underwriting. Sequence transfers with your lender.
- Assuming proceeds count as reserves. Some lenders allow cash-out proceeds to satisfy reserve requirements; others don't. Ask before you rely on it.
- Ignoring the smaller-tool option. If you only need modest, flexible capital and your current first-lien rate is excellent, a HELOC on the rental can beat resetting your entire balance at cash-out pricing.
Price your cash-out scenario in minutes
Tell us the property value, current balance, and rent, and we'll price your cash-out across conventional and DSCR lenders. No documents, no login — live indicative pricing as you answer, then a licensed loan officer reviews your exact scenario.
RUN MY SCENARIO →